| Sport |
Name |
Year(s) |
Award |
| M. Basketball |
John Alexander |
1974 |
1974 NAIA All-American Honorable Mention |
| M. Basketball |
Mike Johnston |
1974 |
1974 NAIA All-American Honorable Mention |
| M. Basketball |
Jeff Creech |
1985, 1986 |
'85 NAIA Hon. Mention, '86 NAIA Hon. Mention, NABC 2nd Team, Kodak 3rd Team |
| Baseball |
Bill Mucci |
1985 |
1985 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| Baseball |
Kevin Fitzgerald |
1986 |
1986 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| Baseball |
Arlo Pike |
1986 |
1986 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| Cross Country |
George Bockus |
1987 |
1987 All-American |
| W. Basketball |
Carolyn Brooks |
1988 |
1988 NAIA Honorable Mention, Kodak All-American All-District |
| Cross Country |
Scott Roberts |
1988 |
1988 All-American |
| W. Basketball |
Kendra Coates |
1991 |
1991 NAIA All-American, 1991 Bill Bradley Scholastic All-American |
| Baseball |
Leon Renaud |
1990, 1991, 1992 |
1990 NAIA All-American, 1991 NAIA All-American, 1992 NAIA All-American |
| M. Basketball |
Greg Collymore |
1991, 1993 |
1991 NAIA Honorable Mention, 1993 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| W. Soccer |
Kelly Wood |
1993 |
|
| M. Basketball |
Jamie Header |
1993 |
1993 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| M. Basketball |
Steve Schuler |
1993, 1994 |
1993 NAIA Honorable Mention, 1994 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| W. Basketball |
Sharon Rines |
1993, 1994 |
1993 Kodak All-American, 1994 Kodak All-American |
| Softball |
Dani Waterman |
1994 |
|
| Volleyball |
Karen Heslin |
1995 |
|
| W. Basketball |
Danielle Bouchard |
1995 |
1995 NAIA 2nd Team |
| Baseball |
Doug Mayo |
1995 |
1995 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| M. Basketball |
John Wassenbergh |
1995, 1996 |
1995 NAIA 3rd Team, 1996 NAIA 2nd Team All-American |
| Softball |
Kellee Murphy |
1996 |
1996 NAIA All-American |
| M. Basketball |
Kyle Sewer |
1997 |
1997 NAIA Third Team |
| M. Basketball |
Carl Howell |
1997, 1998, 1999 |
1997 NAIA Honorable Mention, 1998 NAIA 2nd Team, 1996 NAIA 1st Team |
| M. Soccer |
Michael Bolanz |
1998 |
|
| Baseball |
David Quintal |
1999 |
|
| Baseball |
Steve Osborne |
1999, 2000, 2001 |
1999 NAIA Hon. Mention, 2000 NAIA Hon. Mention, 2001 NAIA Hon. Mention |
| Baseball |
Jesse LaCasse |
2000 |
2000 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| W. Basketball |
Stacey Gelinas |
2001 |
2001 Kodak All-American |
| W. Basketball |
Sue Picard |
2001 |
2001 Kodak All-American |
| M. Soccer |
Jesse Beer |
2001 |
|
| M. Basketball |
C.J. Vose |
2001 |
2001 NAIA Honorable Mention, 2002 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| Baseball |
Brent Dan |
2001 |
2001 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| M. Basketball |
Bilal Dawan-Abdullah |
2002 |
2002 NAIA Honorable Mention |
| Baseball |
Charlie Furbush |
2006 |
NCAA DIII 2nd Team All-American |
| Baseball |
Luke Enman |
2007 |
2007 D3baseball.com 2nd Team |
| Baseball |
Ian Lee |
2009 |
2009 D3baseball.com Honorable Mention |
| Baseball |
Pat Moran |
2009 |
2009 D3baseball.com Honorable Mention |
| Baseball |
Todd Keneborus (2) |
2010 |
2010 ABCA/Rawlings 3rd Team, 2010 D3Baseball.com 3rd Team |
| Field Hockey |
Meaghan Johnson |
2011 |
2011 Longstreth/NFHCA 3rd Team |
| Baseball |
Chad Rafferty (2) |
2012 |
2012 ABCA/Rawlings NCAA Division III 3rd Team, 2012 D3Baseball 3rd Team |
| M. Soccer |
Dalton Gaumer (2) |
2017, 2018 |
2017 U.S.C. 3rd Team, 2017 D3soccer.com 3rd Team, 2018 U.S.C. 3rd Team |
| M. Soccer |
Blake Mullen |
2017, 2018 |
2017 D3soccer.com 2nd Team, 2018 D3soccer.com 2nd Team |
| Field Hockey |
Libby Pomerleau |
2018, 2019 |
2018 Synapse Sports 3rd Team , 2019 Synapse Sports 3rd Team |
| W. Basketball |
Kelsi McNamara (2) |
2019 |
2019 D3hoops.com 3rd Team, 2019 WBCA Honorable Mention |
| Baseball |
Joey Murphy |
2019 |
2019 D3baseball.com Fourth Team |
| W. Basketball |
Cassandra Stapelfeld |
2022 |
2022 Women's Basketball Coaches Association (WBCA) Honorable Mention |
| M. Basketball |
Remijo Wani |
2025 |
2025 NABC Second Team |
